Description:
Losing customers is inevitable. Here’s how to win them back and keep them renewing policies for years to come.
Winning Back Lost Clients: A Step-by-Step Guide
It seems like a nightmare scenario: a loyal customer drops you out of nowhere. Then, they turn to a competitor’s product, and your relationship with them is suddenly over.
Or is it?
While you can’t win back every client, there are ways to reclaim customers who have strayed and build an 83% average retention rate. And in this guide, we’ll show you how.
Laying the Foundation
A successful customer win-back strategy starts with understanding why customers leave in the first place.
Understanding the Psychology of Sales
Fundamentally, selling insurance isn’t too different from selling any other service. It requires understanding the customer’s psychology and eliminating any objections preventing them from taking the plunge.
Remember that people purchase based on emotion, not logic. When convincing a former client to return, the objective must shift from selling a product to solving a problem.
By refocusing the conversation on the customer—and creating a sense of trust—you can reignite relationships with those who are no longer feeling your value.
Determining Why They Left
It’s impossible to fix the problem until you know what it is. Here are the most common reasons clients will leave your agency:
1. They Found a More Affordable Rate
Let’s be honest—many clients are suckers for cheaper rates. And when other agencies dangle deals in front of them, they can’t help but take the bait.
2. They Had a Bad Experience
If customers feel slighted, taken advantage of, or mistreated, they’ll likely walk away quickly. Unfortunately, it’s hard to come back from this, which is why it’s so important to provide top-notch service from the beginning.
3. They Have Nothing to Insure Anymore
Sometimes customers don’t need your services anymore. It’s not personal—they just don’t have anything to insure or are going through a different life stage.
However, this doesn’t mean you can’t stay in touch with them. They’ll know exactly who to call when they eventually need another policy.
Tracking Customer KPIs
KPIs, or key performance indicators, are essential metrics for any company. It’s the only way to truly gauge how well your policies—and customer service—are performing.
The KPIs most relevant to insurance are:
- Churn rate. The rate at which customers cancel their policies.
- Customer retention rate. The rate at which customers renew their policies.
- Existing customer revenue growth rate. The rate at which customers increase their premiums or policies.
- Customer lifetime value. The total revenue an individual customer contributes to your agency.
To calculate your retention rate, use the following equation:
Retention rate = (# of customers at the end of the period – # of new customers in the period) / # of customers at the beginning of the period)
This formula empowers you to track customer churn and retention over time, helping you identify any improvement areas—whether in policy offerings or customer service.
Winning Them Back
Now that you’ve identified the problem and the metrics that signify it, you can start to win lost clients back. Here’s how:
1. Create Personalized Campaigns
A campaign that doesn’t acknowledge the prior relationship will never work. To hit the right cord, you must tailor your message to the individual involved.
For example, you can remind a former client who canceled their policy after finding a better rate of the value and loyalty they enjoyed while they were customers. Or, if they left after a bad experience, apologize and make amends as best you can.
2. Offer Incentives
Incentives are a great way to sway clients back to your agency. But don’t get too fancy—simple offers like discounted premiums or special discounts can be just as effective.
And hey, there’s nothing wrong with a good ol’ fashioned Amazon gift card. If the customer was uninsured for an extended period, they’re likely feeling the financial pinch—so something that helps make ends meet is even better.
3. Communicate Effectively
When it comes to customer win-backs, communication is vital. Timing is also crucial— get in touch when the customer is likely still to have the policy cancellation fresh in their mind.
It never hurts to ask them how they’ve been since leaving your coverage. Find out if they turned to another firm and if they’ve been happy with the switch.
4. Educate Them on Improvements
Once you’ve established the conversation, it’s time to explain why they should return. Enlighten them on any changes or improvements made to the policy and customer service—perhaps a new app or discounts for long-term customers.
Remember, the key to customer win-back success lies in understanding the customer’s psychology and tailoring the message accordingly. That’s the only way to prove your worth and revive former relationships.
5. Offer a New Bundle
If all else fails, you can try bundling your services with another company’s offerings to create a unique package.
Not only will this appeal to customers on a budget, but it may even help you win over new customers who may have previously discounted your services too pricey. For example, if you offer auto insurance, you can bundle it with roadside assistance to attract a whole new subset of buyers.
6. Remind Them Why They Chose You Initially
Customers rarely forget the reasons why they chose a specific service in the first place. Reinforcing these reasons can be a great way to get former users back on board.
Do you know why a client signed up for your auto insurance policy in the first place? Was it easy to sign up? Did you offer a free quote? Did they like the customer service reps?
Remind them of the benefits that made them choose you the first time and why those benefits still stand today. If you show them you understand their needs, they’ll be more likely to return.
7. Correct Your Mistakes
If a customer leaves due to a bad experience, take a good, hard look at the situation. Where did things go wrong? What can you do to prevent a similar issue in the future?
Apologize and rise to the challenge of making it up to them. It may be as simple as offering a discount or a bonus service—or as involved as completely restructuring your customer service policies.
Either way, show them you’re serious about improvement.
8. Monitor Your Competitors
Chances are your competitors are doing things you’re not—and that may be why customers are leaving your agency. So monitor the competition over time to get a sense of what they’re doing differently—and how you can do it better.
If they’re offering lower rates, find out how. If they’re providing stellar customer service, take notes. If they’re offering unique services, investigate further.
Once They’ve Returned…
When a client returns to your agency, it’s essential to show them you mean business.
Welcome them back with open arms and provide a streamlined experience. Follow up with them after they’ve renewed their policy to ensure they’re satisfied; ask them for feedback and how you can improve.
Furthermore, be upfront about any changes in policies.
If there’s been a shift in premiums or a new clause, explain why and how it affects them. The more understanding and explorative you are, the better chance the customer will stick around for the long haul.
You’ll also want to make their new experience as convenient as possible. Offer autopsy options, electronic payments, and a customer service rep they can contact directly.
Going the extra mile and providing an easy, seamless experience for returning customers will significantly increase the chances of them staying with you for years to come.
Enroll in Insurance Bob for More
We’re passionate about helping independent insurance agents succeed. That’s why we offer a range of courses to help you hone your skills, build your business, and remain competitive in an ever-changing market.
If you’re looking to win back lost clients, or any other secrets to success, check out our Insurance Bob course. It’s a free, 20-day boot camp that covers every aspect of the insurance industry—from sales to customer service.
Whether you’re just starting out or already an experienced agent, Insurance Bob will help you get a competitive advantage. So sign up today and get the resources you need to make customer win-back easy and effective.